Our, "Sooo much more helpful thanSparkNotes. He wanted put his mouth there and nibble it slowly, leaving it black and blue (Baldwin, 19). When he attempted to rape Dana . Alice wants Dana to keep resisting her life as a slave, even when it is far easier to simply be obedient. As Rufus grow up , he becomes likely white person in slavery time . Jealousy alone is one of the leading causes of irrational decision-making in our society. Toms selfishness constantly wins out over helping anyone else. The relationship between Alice Pieszecki and Dana Fairbanks began when they met and became best friends five years before "Pilot". You'll also get updates on new titles we publish and the ability to save highlights and notes. It is shown through the characters Genevieve Heart, Hatter Madigan, and Alyss Heart. Both Dana and Alice have to become slaves on a plantation, run away for a life of freedom, and tolerate the treatment of Rufus. Alice desperately searches for freedom because she sees herself becoming twisted to Rufuss will the more she comes to like him. Complete your free account to request a guide. Youve got to hear of these things before you can imagine them.-Bullshit. Does Alice use Dana? Alice is an intense character who only acts submissive when it is necessary for her survival, but she mostly sticks to her beliefs and is stubborn. Butler presents the lives of slaves in the house and in the field as a series of choices. 7. Who is Alice? In this book there are many themes evident. Edna continually questions whether or not she is destined to live a life of subordination or if she can find her own freedom. Rufus abuses Dana on the subject of Kevin, suggesting that maybe Kevin wants to be with "his own kind." Her name is Alice Greenwood, and she converts into a slave because of her first partner because she was born as a free black woman. Alices culture and background are the foundation of every decision she makes and thus, throughout the entire autobiography, the reader observes the implications of this, and often, the divide this creates. Dana states: "It was that destructive single . Does Alice also use Dana? From her perspective, white people are. Though she may no longer care about Rufus, Dana still feels a sense of kinship with her fellow slaves. Kindred glances at the act of servitude in the American South according to the point of view of an individual of color during the 1970s. She is thus willing to risk the chance that cutting her wrists will actually kill her instead of just sending her to the present. She hates Dana's hold over Kevin. Both searched for freedom and had dedication to help free others. Dana needs to keep Rufus alive long enough, so that Rufus and Alice could have Dana's ancestor. 15. What does Dana do while she is waiting to return to the past? The chapters are lengthy, so that is still a lot of material to comb through. from Dordt University. Family conflict is a predominant theme in the story and all members of her family directly face it. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. Rufus says he recalls the scene and didnt recognize her because she was wearing pants like a man (Butler, 22). Meanwhile, Dana has to again save Rufus to keep herself safe, this time wary of a punishment from Tom if Rufus worsens. One is making sacrifices for the good of others. I introduce them to the idea of a slave narrative, having them read an excerpt from Frederick Douglass's narrative. how does rufus use dana to get to aliceis chris herren still married. Alice is like an antebellum-South version of Dana, a living reminder of what Dana's life might have been like had she been born earlier. The important crux of the novel is Catherines eclaircissement, not only to her own navety, but to the oppression under which Eleanor lives, as fantasy, gives way to cruelty, as Eleanor states; After courting you from the protection of real friends to this almost double distance from your home, to have you driven out of the house, without the considerations even of decent civility.. (Austen, 2008). Choose a specific incident; and determine who holds power over whom and assess how it affects that situation. Already a member? In both versions, The Crucible and Salem Falls, the audience learns that jealousy blinds decision-making and ultimately leads to discontent; however, since Picoults antagonist atones for her jealousy, audiences are more satisfied with the movies ending. Dana always swoops in and saves him in one way or another, so it appears to Rufus that Dana is his guardian angel. Compare Dana's professional life in the present with her life as a slave inKindred. Rufus. Choose a specific incident; and determine who holds power over whom and assess how it affects that situation. Rufus uses Alice as a victim for Dana to protect because her queue to leave would be her future child, Hagar. The ship was a disgusting place with no clean places to sleep, no clean food and no bathrooms for the slaves. Not only has Alice had to allow Rufus to rape her, but she is also scorned by other slaves, who only see that Alice gets to live in the house and do easier tasks because of her position as mistress. She hates Dana's ability to read and write, and her educated way of speaking. This writing is for herself alone, and a huge symbol of the mental freedom that Dana fights to maintain even when she is a slave. Rufus says that if Dana doesn't convince Alice to do this, then he will make the women's lives miserable. Yet Dana still has to compromise her own desires to protect this small benefit, as when she cuts short her conversation with Sam to keep Rufus from getting jealous. Dana does not know about it right away, but one day Rufus leaves to go into town to get Alice. Dana and Kevin feel an obligation to help those people and so define their home based on where their community is. Read More. In contrast, Nigel is a doting father to his sons, and Alice clearly loves Joe fiercely even if she hates how Joe was conceived. Dana rolls Rufus onto his back and assesses the injuries, deeming them fairly minimal. Dana found it hard to get a job when she was married to a white man There was no tension The families did not know how they were going to educate their offspring Question 2 30 seconds Q. how does rufus use dana to get to alice. At this point she realized the bigger picture, that she and her friends were different because of their skin color., In the book Romiette and Julio by Sharon Drapers showed the conflict that two young lover from different religion had to face in the world of discrimination. Afi, a slave on the same ship as Amari, helps her get through tough times by talking to her. How does Rufus' home differ from the slaves' homes? Although she does not immediately accept her position, Alice's will is broken over time. The memoir fluidly transitions between a series of themes and ideas, but through these a constant concept is explored; the cultural divide. Analysis: The Fall, Parts 5-8. The needs and well-being of other residents of the plantation create a web of obligation that is difficult to navigate. "So what else do I have to lose?" Alice later bears two children with Rufus, Joseph and Hagar - and Hagar turns out to be Dana 's great-grandmother. Throughout the story Dee goes back and forth on being proud and, The Relationship between Rufus, Dana, and Alice in Kindred. She is never the same after this and gains the desire to run away more after he is gone. Why does Rufus use Dana to get to Alice? Rufus's charming ways makes it easy, for Dana and for us, to forget that his behavior is frequently monstrous. Rufus, taking the place that Kevin has previously held, shows some mercy by getting Dana back to the house, but he has no concept of compassion for the pain that Dana has just endured. According to the book "Kindred", Dana says "maybe that was why we didn't hate each other. He longs to be loved but expects to always get his way, using coercion and violence if he is denied. Rufus uses her to share his feeling. Arts & Humanities English English Literature. In one passage she cries and feels pity for herself, and in the following she expresses maternal compassion and care for others. When Dana and Kevin return from the past together, she thinks: "I felt as though I were losing my place here in my own time. Jacobs attributes the success of her escape to a communal effort, but the importance of relationships in her narrative extends far beyond this aspect of her story. Dana is furious, and tells him that he killed Alice. 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Though Kevins presence was helpful to Dana in the past, it is more important that he stay away from that poisonous society and give Dana a safe home to come back to in the present. Dana could kill Rufus, though that would cost the whole plantation to being sold. He tells Lily about his plans is chapter 7 Ive just never heard of a Negro lawyer, thats all. Edna Pontelliers defiant nature is brought out. How would you feel toward Rufus if you were in their situation? Dana has become so used to accepting the blame for everything while living as a slave that she even wonders if it is her fault that Kevin got stranded though Dana has no control over her travels through time. Then he says that he sold Sam because he wanted Dana. Why does Alice do it? Sarah worries that Dana's frank talk is going to get her in trouble. Comments (0) Answer & Explanation. Dana tells Rufus she wants to write another letter to Kevin. The slaves are far more vulnerable to disease, as they have less nutritious food and worse living quarters than their masters, so it is even more important that Dana keep Rufus quarantined behind nets. He longs to be loved but expects to always get his way, using coercion and violence if he is denied. Despite the insistence of the Lady that Everythings got an ethical, if solely you can realize it (Carroll, 1993, p.89), Alice finds no ethical here in Wonderland, unless the thought that you just should learn to air your own to fight your own battle in an exceedingly hostile environment. What does Rufus want Dana to call him? 16. Does Alice also use Dana?" This question requires three different answers for each three Why does Rufus use Dana to get to Alice in Kindred? The lifestyle of the charaters in both stories go from calm to abnormal, they differ in scary elements. Click to see full answer. There is relationship with Alice as his slave, which is unimaginable in that time. Because they live on the Weylin plantation, the slaves seem to feel some belonging with the Weylin family. Rufus always looks for the easy way out, as when he asks Dana for a modern pen instead of dealing with the tricky ink pens of his time. This is an external conflict because he is fighting against. The Lord, my body, and my family are the only things I still have to myself in, At the start of the book a nave, young and innocent African American girl lived life almost oblivious to the socially constructed issue of race. Macbeth) in the essay title portion of your citation. A young black woman writer living in the end of the twentieth century, she finds herself plunged into the antebellum South of the nineteenth century, an alien world in which she must struggle to establish an identity and to maintain her freedom. When he does this she realizes it, and fights against him and eventually kills him. The needs and well-being of other residents of the plantation create a web of obligation that is difficult to navigate. Though their home in the present is not as difficult or demanding as their time in the past, Dana and Kevin also feel less connection to this place because they felt such a strong sense of belonging with the people in the past with whom they shared such suffering. He longs to be loved but expects to always get his way, using coercion and violence if he is denied. From yours? Struggling with distance learning? She does challenge a few historians such as: Bertram Wyatt-Brown and Steven Stowe. Rufus tries to have power over Dana and Alice who are both black. Who does Dana teach to read that gets her whipped? Dana is again confronted with her lack of power and agency in this time, as she has little choice but to stay on the Weylin plantation after learning how dangerous it is to try to run away. Dana reflects that Rufus loves her because she cares about him. Choose a specific incident; and determine who holds power over whom and assess how it affects that situation. Meanwhile, Rufus seems to see both Alice and Dana as two halves of a wife, with Alice providing the romantic component and Dana supplying the work partnership and companionship. I knew that we were going to separate schools and all, but I never knew why.1 At this point her innocence was lost and confusion took hold of her. Carrie again shows great thoughtfulness by telling Margaret that Dana is sick so that Dana has time to process the sale that she just witnessed. Dana decides to run away from the plantation when she finds out. Often times when a person is forced to outwardly conform while questioning themselves it leads to a struggle between their inner selves and what is expected of them. See Page 1. She waits for Rufus to wake up, hoping that Alice and Isaac will have a good head start in fleeing. Despite the abuse Dana has just suffered at a white persons hands, she is still capable of remembering that white people (like Kevin) can show love and mercy. Does Alice use Dana? Choose a specific incident and determine who holds power over whom; assess how it affects the situation. Edward P. Jones, I, Mattie Curtis, have already done the unacceptable. The character of Alice is the ancestor of Dana. How does she get him to agree? Rufus thinks only of forcing Dana to be obedient to his will, assuming that women (especially black women) owe him their submission.